- Cranford (6-2)
- Union (4-3)
- Rahway (5-1)
- New Providence (8-1)
- Scotch Plains-Fanwood (5-2)
- Brearley (6-2)
- Governor Livingston (4-2)
- Hillside (4-2)
- Summit (2-3)
- Elizabeth (2-4)
Other teams considered: Linden (1–4), Plainfield (2-3), A.L. Johnson (1-3), and Jonathan Dayton (1-2).