Some Thoughts on the NJSIAA’s State Finals Decision

Phillipsburg, the lone Big Central Conference school still playing on Thanksgiving, will have to play two games in four days after the NJSIAA announced that all seven of its state championship football games will be played at Met Life Stadium in East Rutherford on November 28th and 29th.

The NJSIAA Forces Teams Playing on Thanksgiving to Play Two Games in Four Days

SOUTH PLAINFIELD, NJ – Last Wednesday, the NJSIAA announced the schedule for this year’s state finals in football.  With both the Jets and Giants playing games on the road over Thanksgiving Weekend, the NJSIAA decided to have all seven state finals on Saturday, November 28th and Sunday, November 29th.

Four games will be played on November 28th, while the remaining three will take place on November 29th.  There will be no accommodation for teams still playing in Thanksgiving Day contests.  As a result, teams playing on the holiday will have to play two games in four days.  

Watch highlights from the action in Phillipsburg’s win over Bridgewater-Raritan on October 25, 2024.

Only one school in the Big Central is affected by the decision.  Phillipsburg is the lone remaining school in the BCC still playing on the holiday.  The Stateliners play Easton in one of the longest running rivalries, and that is likely to continue for the foreseeable future.

Phillipsburg’s superintendent, Greg Troxell, promptly responded to the NJSIAA’s ultimatum by stating that the Liners will do both this year if the situation arises.  Troxell indicated that he supports the NJSIAA’s playoff schedule, but is “proud of the Easton-Phillipsburg Thanksgiving tradition.”  There are still 26 New Jersey schools playing on Thanksgiving.

Watch highlights from the action in Phillipsburg’s win over Easton on Thanksgiving Day 2023.

Several of those schools are Phillipsburg, Shabazz and Camden, who will likely be in contention for a statewide group title come November.  All three schools were also affected by the NJSIAA’s success policy and moved up a group last December.  Phillipsburg now plays in Group 5, while Shabazz and Camden are in Group 3.  Another Group 3 school, Manasquan, and perennial Group 4 contenders, Millville and Middletown South are also affected.


Statewide Thanksgiving Football Schedule in 2026

Wednesday, November 25th

  • Camden Catholic at Paul VI, 6:00 PM

Thursday, November 26th

  • Atlantic City at Holy Spirit, 10:00 AM
  • Millville at Vineland, 10:00 AM
  • Dumont at Tenafly, 10:00 AM
  • East Orange Campus at Barringer, 10:30 AM
  • Clayton at Pitman, 10:30 AM
  • Phillipsburg vs. Easton at Lafayette College, 10:30 AM
  • Hackensack at Teaneck, 10:30 AM
  • Weequahic at Shabazz, 10:30 AM
  • Hamilton at Steinert, 10:30 AM
  • Middletown North at Middletown South, 10:45 AM
  • Haddon Township at Audubon, 11:00 AM
  • Haddon Heights at Haddonfield, 11:00 AM
  • Wall Township at Manasquan, 11:00 AM
  • Camden at Camden Eastside, 11:00 AM

No governing body, whether it be the NJSIAA, the Big Central Conference, the Greater Middlesex Conference, the Skyland Conference, or the Union County Conference should impose its will on a member school when it comes to things such as Thanksgiving Day Games.  If Phillipsburg wants to continue honoring its tradition and keep playing on Thanksgiving, it should be able to do it.  The governing body should be able to accommodate that school.

In recent years, governing bodies such as the NJSIAA and conferences have attempted to compel schools to comply to their wishes.  Following the 2018-19 season, the Greater Middlesex Conference attempted to coerce Dunellen, one of the smallest schools in the conference, to move up from the Gold to the Blue Division in boys basketball, and play larger schools, including Carteret and South Plainfield as well as St. Thomas Aquinas.

Watch Big Central Gridiron’s 35-minute movie from the action in Phillipsburg’s 47-12 win over Easton on Thanksgiving Day 2023.

Dunellen refused to move and was punished by not being recognized as the Gold Division champion in the 2019-20 season.  Thanksgiving Day Games have been on the decline.  The last Turkey Day games in Middlesex County were played in 2018.  Some games were still played around the holiday during the COVID shortened season of 2020.  The Big Central Conference began with four Thanksgiving Day games.  Now it is down to one.

Roselle and Roselle Park was the latest Turkey Day game that was moved to the regular season.  The two teams played in the final holiday game in the series last November at Herm Shaw Field in Roselle Park.  The Panthers defeated the Rams 41-19.  In recent years, the two teams alternated between playing on Thanksgiving Eve at Arminio Field in Roselle and Thanksgiving Day at Herm Shaw Field in Roselle Park.

Watch highlights from Phillipsburg’s freshmen win over Easton at Maloney Stadium on November 6, 2023.

Westfield and Plainfield played their last Thanksgiving Day game in 2024, while New Providence and Governor Livingston halted playing on the holiday after the Pioneers defeated the Highlanders in 2021.  Now, Phillipsburg’s annual game is the only Big Central contest played on the holiday.  Changes in the state playoff schedule starting in 2018, which led to having one state champion in every group starting in 2022.  

Thanksgiving Day games may be a fading tradition in New Jersey, but schools that wish to continue the ritual should be able to do so.  Phillipsburg still believes in the importance of its holiday game with Easton because what it means to its community.  These rivalry games are a source of pride and passion for the towns still participating in them.  These wishes should be respected.

Watch highlights from Phillipsburg’s JV football win over Easton at Maloney Stadium on November 3, 2025.